Local SEO GuideTroubleshooting

Ranking Drops

Diagnosing and recovering from local search ranking decreases

Ranking drops can happen suddenly or gradually. Understanding why helps you recover faster.

Types of Ranking Drops

Sudden Drop

  • Overnight ranking loss
  • Usually algorithm or penalty related
  • Often affects specific rankings

Gradual Decline

  • Slow erosion over weeks/months
  • Often competition-related
  • Harder to pinpoint cause

Partial Drop

  • Lost rankings for some keywords
  • Others remain stable
  • May indicate targeted issue

Diagnosis Process

Step 1: Verify the Drop

Confirm it's real:

  • Check from different devices
  • Use incognito/private browsing
  • Check from different locations
  • Use rank tracking tools

Rule out:

  • Personalized results
  • Location-based variations
  • Temporary fluctuations
  • Tool inaccuracies

Step 2: Check Timeline

Correlate with events:

  • Algorithm updates
  • Changes you made
  • Competitor actions
  • Industry events

Step 3: Identify Scope

Determine what's affected:

  • All keywords or specific ones?
  • Local pack only or organic too?
  • Desktop and mobile?
  • One location or all?

Common Causes and Solutions

Google Algorithm Updates

Symptoms:

  • Drop coincides with announced update
  • Many businesses affected
  • Industry-wide discussions

Solutions:

  • Research the specific update
  • Identify what it targets
  • Adjust strategy accordingly
  • Wait for dust to settle

Guideline Violations

Symptoms:

  • Sudden, severe drop
  • Possible suspension notice
  • Specific violation warnings

Solutions:

  • Review Google's guidelines
  • Fix any violations immediately
  • Request reinstatement if needed
  • Ensure full compliance

Competitor Improvements

Symptoms:

  • Gradual decline
  • Competitors ranking higher
  • Your metrics unchanged

Solutions:

  • Analyze competitor changes
  • Improve your optimization
  • Focus on differentiators
  • Build more reviews/citations

Negative SEO or Spam

Symptoms:

  • Unusual backlink patterns
  • Spam reviews appearing
  • Citation inconsistencies

Solutions:

  • Audit your backlinks
  • Disavow toxic links
  • Report spam reviews
  • Clean up citations

Website Technical Issues

Symptoms:

  • Site speed problems
  • Mobile issues
  • Crawl errors
  • SSL problems

Solutions:

  • Run technical SEO audit
  • Fix site speed issues
  • Ensure mobile-friendliness
  • Resolve crawl errors

GBP Changes or Issues

Symptoms:

  • Information changed unexpectedly
  • Listing edits by Google
  • Category changes

Solutions:

  • Audit your GBP listing
  • Correct any wrong information
  • Re-verify accuracy
  • Check for suggested edits

Investigation Checklist

GBP Audit

  • Verify business information is correct
  • Check for Google-suggested edits
  • Review category accuracy
  • Confirm verification status
  • Check for duplicate listings
  • Review recent changes

Website Audit

  • Check for technical errors
  • Verify mobile-friendliness
  • Test page speed
  • Review on-page SEO
  • Check for manual actions in Search Console

Citation Audit

  • Verify NAP consistency
  • Check major directories
  • Look for conflicting information
  • Review recent citation changes

Review Audit

  • Check for spam reviews
  • Review recent negative reviews
  • Assess overall sentiment
  • Compare to competitors

Competition Analysis

  • Track competitor rankings
  • Analyze their recent changes
  • Compare optimization levels
  • Identify their improvements

Recovery Strategies

Immediate Actions

  1. Fix any obvious issues
  2. Correct GBP information
  3. Address technical problems
  4. Remove guideline violations

Short-Term Actions

  1. Increase optimization efforts
  2. Request more reviews
  3. Clean up citations
  4. Improve content quality

Long-Term Actions

  1. Build sustainable advantages
  2. Focus on customer experience
  3. Develop unique differentiators
  4. Monitor consistently

When to Wait vs. Act

Wait When:

  • Drop is minor (1-2 positions)
  • Algorithm update just happened
  • No clear cause identified
  • Fluctuation is normal pattern

Act When:

  • Drop is significant (page 2+)
  • Clear cause is identified
  • Violation exists
  • Issue is fixable

Preventing Future Drops

Regular Monitoring

  • Track rankings weekly
  • Monitor GBP insights
  • Watch for changes
  • Set up alerts

Proactive Optimization

  • Stay current with best practices
  • Continuously improve listing
  • Build review momentum
  • Maintain citation accuracy

Diversified Strategy

  • Don't rely on one factor
  • Build comprehensive presence
  • Multiple traffic sources
  • Strong website AND GBP

Key Takeaways

  1. Verify drops are real before reacting
  2. Identify the specific cause
  3. Fix violations and issues immediately
  4. Be patient with algorithm fluctuations
  5. Build sustainable, diversified presence

On this page